On the Division of Knowledge
This essay is an adaptation of a speech I gave at my Toastmasters club.
If you’ve been human long enough, you’ve probably once asked questions of this nature: What does it mean to live a good life? How do I know what to believe? How should we govern ourselves? What should we allow AI to do on our behalf? As much as I would gladly give my unsolicited opinion on these issues, it is beyond the scope of this essay to answer them. As to the above-listed questions, one thing is clear: they don’t arrive with a label stating what division they belong to nor do they come with instructions on how to solve them. They are no respecter of titles, vocations, nor academic qualifications — they are simply human questions, which means they confront or will eventually confront every one of us.
We might object that these questions are merely theoretical, abstractions with no real bearing on our lives, or that they simply don’t concern us. Try defending that position for more than a moment and watch it fall apart. We vote. We work. We use technology that quietly reshapes how we think and relate. We trust institutions, or decide not to. We make moral choices every single day, examined or not. There is no exemption, no neutral ground where we get to stand outside these questions and watch them from a safe theoretical distance — we are already living inside the consequences of answers to them, whether we’ve bothered to ask them or not. We are, borrowing Pascal’s image, embarqués: embarked.1 It is not optional! We are at the mercy of these questions, and our answers at the mercy of our tools. By tools, I speak not of screwdrivers and hammers but of tools of the mind!
Allow me to reach for the powerful opening scene of one of my favourite plays, John Logan’s Red, where Rothko goes on a rant to his young assistant, Ken, a budding painter, asking if he had read Nietzsche, Freud, Jung, ancient Greek dramatists and Shakespeare. Rothko follows with something profound: “You cannot be an artist until you are civilized. You cannot be civilized until you learn,”2 and lists out a plethora of disciplines: Philosophy, Theology, Archaeology, Music, Literature, Poetry, Drama, History. We might wonder, what does a painter have to do with these numerous subjects? Rothko doesn’t leave us in the dark much longer. He says to the young Ken, “These are your tools as much as brush and pigment.”2
I submit that we all, as humans, are painters! We might not all be painting on a physical canvas, but our lives are an artistic work in the making. We start on a blank canvas at birth and paint the stories of our lived experiences till we die. Our ability to paint a piece that is worthy of and does justice to our lived experiences depends greatly on the tools we have available to us — tools as much as brush and pigment. We must, however, be aware that having access to these tools does not necessarily guarantee a correct judgement. Their value lies rather in enabling us to see more clearly what is before us, to detect what might otherwise escape our notice, and to judge with greater care.
Take the prevailing question on what AI should be able to do or what parts of our lives it should be allowed in: it would be rather presumptuous to assume this question is simply a technological problem. It contains technical, ethical, economic, psychological, political, historical and legal dimensions. Think of disciplines as specialised ways of seeing. Science asks: what is true? History asks: what has happened before, and under what conditions? Philosophy asks: what concepts and values are actually at stake? Psychology asks: how do humans behave and respond? Politics and law ask: who gets power, rights and responsibility? Literature and art ask: what does an experience look like from inside a human life? Each lens is valuable, and each is partial. Approaching the problem through any one of them will inadvertently leave a lot of things out. A computer scientist may understand exactly what an AI system can do while having no special competence for deciding what it ought to do. A philosopher might reason beautifully about autonomy while misunderstanding the actual capabilities of the technology.
At this juncture, one obvious question to pose would be why the need for such breadth at all? Isn’t the whole point of specialisation that we have philosophers, psychologists, historians, lawyers, scientists and engineers who can contribute their respective expertise to a central problem? When we investigate the reality of specialisation, it’s clear that such division of labour solves the problem of depth but not automatically that of integration. When each discipline helps produce its answers, we still need to understand enough of the different perspectives to weigh and eventually form a synthesis. It then becomes the responsibility of each and every one of us to take up the assignment of integration in our very lives. When faced with these human questions, we are in some sense being asked to become generalists: to recognise the different dimensions of what confronts us and do the work of marrying different perspectives together. We cannot all master every discipline, but the responsibility of weighing what we learn and forming a suitable answer still falls to each and every one of us.
Allow me place myself under the microscope for a minute, I grew up in a family of modest means. Both my parents worked in the civil service. I was schooled mostly in Osun State, Nigeria, then attended senior secondary school and university in Kwara State, where I earned a bachelor’s degree in Electrical Engineering. At senior secondary, I was placed in the Science class. The schools were private but modest, and my parents gave me the best education they could afford. Year after year I moved through subjects that were each complete in themselves, and I never knew to ask how they connected. Lately I have found myself drawn towards the humanities, and I think the reason is self-evident. They feel closer to home: they wrestle with pain, meaning, guilt, hope, and the burden of being human, and the average person will, sooner or later, come to wrestle with these realities. Yet this pull has also been a revealer of my inadequacies.
My schooling taught every subject in silos, and two things followed. First, no one showed me the overarching plot of what was being taught, faith included. I never knew a bigger picture existed, so I never asked why any of it mattered. Second, nothing trained the ability to learn; the schooling was designed to teach specific subjects in isolation. Dorothy L. Sayers, in The Lost Tools of Learning, claims that modern education fails lamentably on the whole in teaching how to think, and that we learn everything except the art of learning.3 My schooling is one case of that claim. Confronted with such cross-disciplinary human questions, I began to see the overarching plot that connects the disciplines, how far I had veered from it, how much I was missing, and, plainly put, how late I have arrived. Yet that plot is exactly what a well-rounded generalist, an integrator of disciplines, needs.
This deficiency was made more apparent when I drove up to see Warwick Castle. Beyond the ethereal look and feel of the castle was a captivating, mind-blowing library. As I stepped in, gazing on the wealth of knowledge in books spanning every discipline one’s mind could comprehend, I was filled with sadness. Here, laid out shelf by shelf, was the map I never got: a charted way through the disciplines, showing how they connect and where each belongs. I began to think of the privileged access the nobles had to such an education and I was at this point no longer sad, no, far from it, I was jealous! This, however, isn’t an investigation into my emotional state of being, but there is no better place to remember the piercing words of Rothko: “To be civilized is to know where you belong in the continuum of your art and your world. To surmount the past, you must know the past.”2 My fear was acute! How do I surmount a past I didn’t even know existed? Here in front of me were entire traditions of thought containing tools I was only now realising I needed.
Wrestling with this feeling caused me to investigate the ways of old with one pressing question: what was education like back then? In my quest, I stumbled on an influential ideal of medieval education, organised around the seven liberal arts. In this scheme, the trivium — grammar, logic and rhetoric — supplied foundational tools of thought and expression. Grammar provided the building blocks of language, logic a method for testing arguments, and rhetoric the means to communicate them.
The trivium was concerned not only with subjects, but with methods for dealing with them. I’ll lean again on Sayers, who described the whole of the trivium as an attempt to teach the pupil the proper use of the tools of learning before applying them to subjects.3 In this scheme, the trivium prepared students for the quadrivium, which explored the mathematical structure of creation: arithmetic, geometry, music and astronomy. The attraction, for me, is that students would approach those disciplines having begun to learn how to learn and how to express critical thought. Actual curricula varied across institutions and periods, and arts study could prepare students for advanced study in theology, law and medicine.4 Aquinas, for one, drew on theology, law, logic and natural philosophy at once.5
At the risk of sounding like a medieval apologist who detests specialisation, I am aware that education wasn’t easily accessible to the common man and the chances of me getting such access back in medieval times were slim. I also need to acknowledge the immense benefits the educational curriculum of our age has brought us. We have experts in domains who have spent their entire lives pursuing the depths of their field and we’ve come to know more about those disciplines thanks to the laser-eye focus of said people. We must remain grateful to them for their devotion but do so being fully aware of the trade-offs we’ve had to make along the way. We can acknowledge what the ways of old gave that we have lost without sinking into despair. Sayers sketched what a return to the tools of learning could look like, and that return is already underway in the classical education movement, which a 2024 survey estimated encompassed more than a thousand schools in the US.6 Its focus, though, is largely on children, so the rest of us must still wrestle with the questions as we are.
Until then, there is a way to live with this, and it is curiosity. Yes, curiosity! For the world has no departments and we are only human, not an engineer, not a banker, not a lawyer! Just human, all too human! Allow your curiosity to be the driver towards new disciplines. Let it take you on a journey of exploring this cosmos of ours filled with beauty and barbed wires. Your curiosity is a summons to acquire a new tool, a tool that will help you paint an even richer story on your life’s canvas, enabling you to provide suitable answers to life’s unlabelled human questions. Hugh of St Victor, in the preface to his twelfth-century Didascalicon, urged readers not to abandon learning because their abilities or resources were limited.7 If that is so, then knowledge is worth fighting for, and no poor start excuses us from the fight. What we learn on our quest for knowledge may complicate an answer we had been quite content with and this is fine. This is progress! So if there be any curiosity, if there be any fascinations, if there be any rabbit hole worth falling down, I beg you to please pursue it like your life depends on it, because it does! The age of the well-rounded generalist will not arrive on its own. We must usher it in.
Footnotes
-
Blaise Pascal, Pensées, “Infini rien” (the wager), Lafuma 418. See the electronic edition’s reconstruction of the passage, p. 1. Pascal’s original is “vous êtes embarqué”; the plural here adapts his image. His immediate subject is the wager concerning God. ↩
-
John Logan, Red (London: Oberon Books, 2009), Scene One. The Donmar Warehouse study guide, written by Domonic Francis and edited by Rosie Dalling, reproduces an extract from the play on pp. 22–24. These quotations appear on p. 24; the linked copy is a mirror of the original production document. Rothko’s dialogue is Logan’s dramatic portrayal, rather than a transcript of the historical painter. ↩ ↩2 ↩3
-
Dorothy L. Sayers, The Lost Tools of Learning (London: Methuen, 1948), originally delivered at an Oxford education course in 1947. Her account presents the trivium as training in the tools of learning; it is a proposal for education as well as an interpretation of the medieval inheritance. ↩ ↩2
-
For the seven liberal arts and their two groupings, see Sayers, The Lost Tools of Learning. For a specific medieval curriculum, see Robert de Courçon’s Statutes for the University of Paris (1215), reproduced in the Medieval Sourcebook. The statutes prescribe a particular mixture of grammar, logic and other texts; the tidy sequence described here is an educational ideal, not a universal medieval timetable. ↩
-
Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, I–II, question 90, “The essence of law”. In a single theological inquiry he brings together Scripture, Roman legal authority, syllogistic reasoning and Aristotle’s Physics, Ethics and Politics. ↩
-
Rachel Alexander Cambre, “Classical Schools in America: A Movement of Hope”, The Heritage Foundation, 26 August 2024, especially “Methodology.” The report estimates more than 1,000 schools and directly examines 882; the figure is an estimate, not a comprehensive census. ↩
-
Hugh of Saint Victor, Didascalicon, Preface; see the Latin text. An English translation is Jerome Taylor’s The Didascalicon of Hugh of Saint Victor: A Medieval Guide to the Arts (Columbia University Press). The preface commends persistence despite limited ability or resources; the call to fight for knowledge that follows is my own conclusion. ↩